The ImmutableString Type

All strings in Rhai are implemented as ImmutableString, which is an alias to Rc<SmartString> (or Arc<SmartString> under sync).

SmartString is used because many strings in scripts are short (fewer than 24 ASCII characters).

An ImmutableString is immutable (i.e. never changes) and therefore can be shared among many users. Cloning an ImmutableString is cheap since it only copies an immutable reference.

Modifying an ImmutableString causes it first to be cloned, and then the modification made to the copy. Therefore, direct string modifications are expensive.

Avoid String Parameters

ImmutableString should be used in place of String for function parameters because using String is very inefficient (the argument is cloned during every function call).

A alternative is to use &str which de-sugars to ImmutableString.

A function with the first parameter being &mut String does not match a string argument passed to it, which has type ImmutableString. In fact, &mut String is treated as an opaque custom type.


#![allow(unused)]
fn main() {
fn slow(s: String) -> i64 { ... }               // string is cloned each call

fn fast1(s: ImmutableString) -> i64 { ... }     // cloning 'ImmutableString' is cheap

fn fast2(s: &str) -> i64 { ... }                // de-sugars to above

fn bad(s: &mut String) { ... }                  // '&mut String' will not match string values
}

Differences from Rust Strings

Internally Rhai strings are stored as UTF-8 just like Rust (they are Rust Strings!), but nevertheless there are major differences.

In Rhai a string is semantically the same as an array of Unicode characters and can be directly indexed (unlike Rust).

This is similar to most other languages (e.g. JavaScript, C#) where strings are stored internally not as UTF-8 but as arrays of UCS-16 or UCS-32.

Individual characters within a Rhai string can also be replaced just as if the string is an array of Unicode characters.

In Rhai, there are also no separate concepts of String and &str (a string slice) as in Rust.

Performance Considerations of Character Indexing

Although Rhai exposes a string as a simple array of char which can be directly indexed to get at a particular character, internally the string is still stored as UTF-8 (native Rust Strings).

All indexing operations require walking through the entire UTF-8 string to find the offset of the particular character position, and therefore is much slower than the simple array indexing for other scripting languages.

This implementation detail is hidden from the user but has a performance implication.

Avoid large scale character-based processing of strings; instead, build an actual array of characters (via the split() method) which can then be manipulated efficiently.